<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:00:58
!startmeeting FESCO (2026-10-13)
<@meetbot:fedora.im>
17:00:59
Meeting started at 2026-10-13 17:00:58 UTC
<@meetbot:fedora.im>
17:00:59
The Meeting name is 'FESCO (2026-10-13)'
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:01:01
!meetingname fesco
<@meetbot:fedora.im>
17:01:02
The Meeting Name is now fesco
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:01:06
!group members fesco
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:01:08
Members of fesco: Fabio Valentini, Máirín Duffy, gotmax23 (@gotmax:matrix.org, @gotmax23:fedora.im), Jef Spaleta, Kevin Fenzi, ngompa (@conan_kudo:matrix.org, @ngompa:fedora.im, @pharaoh_atem:opensuse.org, @ngompa:kde.org, @ngompa:almalinux.im), Michel Lind, Timothée Ravier, Simon de Vlieger, Zbigniew Jędrzejewski-Szmek
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:01:10
!topic Init Process
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:01:11
!hi
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:01:13
zbyszek: Zbigniew Jędrzejewski-Szmek (zbyszek)
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:01:25
morning
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:01:28
!hi
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:01:31
Fabio Valentini 🌈: Fabio Valentini (decathorpe) - he / him / his
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:01:39
!hi
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:01:41
Michel Lind UTC+1: Michel Lind (salimma) - he / him / his
<@siosm:fedora.im>
17:02:23
!hi
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:02:24
Timothée Ravier: Timothée Ravier (siosm) - he / him / his
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:03:22
Neal wrote that he's not feeling well and probably will not join.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:04:17
Is @maxamillion here?
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:04:24
supakeen couldn't make the ELN meeting but I'm not sure if that applies to this too, and duffy is not here obviously so that's 3 of the remaining 4
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:04:26
I don't get the completion for the name…
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:04:29
I'm missing someone then
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:05:00
I think that's all.
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:05:04
gotmax is not here
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:05:16
Ah, but he voted in the ticket 2h ago.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:05:23
Anyway, let's start.
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:05:26
ah ok.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:05:40
!topic Next week's chair
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:06:08
(I think we moved this to the beginning of the meeting.)
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:06:19
Volunteers?
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:06:43
iirc we moved it conditionally if we're already barely at quorum, but we have not written it down / updated the template
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:06:47
but for today it makes sense
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:07:04
trying to think... I *think* I can run it next week if nobody else can
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:07:10
We're *exactly* at quorum ;)
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:07:27
yes, so better decide now before starting discussions where we might lose people :P
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:07:50
!action Michel Lind UTC+1 will chair the next meeting
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:07:52
Thanks.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:07:57
!topic #3689 Offboard FESCo member: duffy
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:07:57
!fesco 3689
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:08:16
We need two more votes in the ticket.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:08:21
Michel Lind UTC+1: please vote
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:08:25
Neal Gompa (Fedora): also needs to vote
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:08:31
oh let me check
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:08:40
why is zodbot not giving us links
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:08:48
!fesco 3689
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:08:48
**fesco/tickets #3689** (https://forge.fedoraproject.org/fesco/tickets/issues/3689):**Offboard FESCo member: duffy**
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:08:48
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:08:48
● **Opened:** 2 weeks ago by decathorpe
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:08:48
● **Last Updated:** 2 hours ago
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:08:48
● **Assignee:** Not Assigned
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:08:50
I was holding off processing anything until it was decided.
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:09:29
+1
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:09:46
!info The vote is progress in the ticket to finalize @maxamillion's seat.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:09:53
Please vote in the ticket.
<@siosm:fedora.im>
17:09:55
Hum, off boarding does not need full consensus, only on-boarding
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:10:07
ah you're not going to combine the votes? makes sense since Neal is not here
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:10:12
sure, but then I have to do one, then basically the same places for the onboarding
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:10:21
voted
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:10:22
I can do it if you really want it done for some reason.
<@siosm:fedora.im>
17:10:46
not really, just noting, but understand that it's less work to do both at the same time
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:10:53
!topic #3687 Reaffirm provenpackager policy bounds
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:10:58
!fesco 3687
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:10:59
**fesco/tickets #3687** (https://forge.fedoraproject.org/fesco/tickets/issues/3687):**Reaffirm provenpackager policy bounds**
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:10:59
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:10:59
● **Opened:** a month ago by zbyszek
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:10:59
● **Last Updated:** 3 hours ago
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:10:59
● **Assignee:** Not Assigned
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:11:21
Dunno, gotmax wanted some changes, maybe, but he's not here…
<@siosm:fedora.im>
17:11:46
:/
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:11:51
Formally, this was already approved by the existing vote.
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:11:51
this one is not urgent right? I guess we can skip it for now
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:11:56
We should really try and send this soon... we are not being very agile. ;)
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:12:25
OK, does anyone who _didn't_ vote in the ticket do so now?
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:13:12
Michel Lind UTC+1 ?
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:14:18
I can't vote on that today, sorry
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:14:40
OK, no problem.
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:14:41
I asked to add a sentence to the end of the announcement. Otherwise the previous draft looked good to me
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:14:48
I don't think we should rush this kind of thing
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:14:59
We're doing the opposite of rushing
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:15:17
The issue was opened a month or so ago…
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:15:24
This draft is already two weeks old.
<@siosm:fedora.im>
17:15:40
gotmax23can you post a "full draft" as a comment so that we can vote on it?
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:15:59
Yes I can do that when I'm back at my laptop
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:16:23
can I note that without a -1 vote on the current draft it should already count as approved?
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:16:38
Yeah.
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:17:09
Yeah, we can just add that sentence and call it a day?
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:17:23
I like myself a good bikeshedding from time to time but extending voting time and stretching rules just for the sake of it is not my definition of fun
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:18:04
> Provenpackgers are a group of package maintainers with access to all packages in Fedora, but these powers also come with limits and should be used responsibly. In particular, we would like to remind everyone that this access should be used only in limited cases (as described in the "Who is allowed to modify which packages" policy document [1]), and should otherwise not be used without consulting affected package maintainers first. Note that "Mass package changes" [2] are covered by a different policy.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:18:04
> For example, provenpackagers should not convert packages to %autorelease/%autochangelog without consent of the package maintainer.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:18:04
> [1] https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/fesco/Who_is_allowed_to_modify_which_packages/
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:18:04
> [2] https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/fesco/Mass_package_changes/
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:18:09
This is the existing draft.
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:18:26
s/provenpackgers/provenpackagers typo
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:18:47
(looks like it's in the tracker too, not just the copy here)
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:18:59
Michel Lind UTC+1: do you want to invalidate existing votes over that or can we agree that this is a minor fix?
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:19:00
Dunno, I think this is good enough and we don't need to add more to it.
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:19:00
I wanted to add "Additionally, provenpackager members are trusted packagers that are considered examples to the rest of the Fedora packaging community and should therefore take extra care to respectfully communicate and collaborate with other developers and closely follow the Packaging Guidelines."
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:19:05
nope, minor fix
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:19:13
If we don't like the addition, we can keep what's there
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:19:23
yeah, I'd like to have this go out with gotmax's addition
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:19:25
I think the first sentence already says something very similar.
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:19:27
I like the addition...
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:19:36
so it's not just doing the right thing, but also fyi what provenpackagers do set an example to others
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:20:37
OK, so:
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:20:37
> Provenpackagers are a group of package maintainers with access to all packages in Fedora, but these powers also come with limits and should be used responsibly. They are trusted packagers that are considered examples to the rest of the Fedora packaging community and should therefore take extra care to respectfully communicate and collaborate with other developers and closely follow the Packaging Guidelines. In particular, we would like to remind everyone that this access should be used only in limited cases (as described in the "Who is allowed to modify which packages" policy document [1]), and should otherwise not be used without consulting affected package maintainers first. Note that "Mass package changes" [2] are covered by a different policy.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:20:37
>
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:20:37
> For example, provenpackagers should not convert packages to %autorelease/%autochangelog without consent of the package maintainer.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:20:39
?
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:21:06
+1
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:21:33
+1 ftr
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:21:40
+1
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:22:02
We also need a volunteer to send this out to devel-announce.
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:22:02
sure. +1
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:22:48
Fabio Valentini 🌈, Timothée Ravier ?
<@siosm:fedora.im>
17:22:53
+1
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:22:59
%nil
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:23:13
Is that a new way to spell '0'?
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:23:30
no, that's a way to say "nothing is here"
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:23:30
you have sufficiently annoyed me that I don't want to vote on this
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:23:47
oookay
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:24:26
!agreed The edited text is approved and will be sent out to devel-announce. (+5, 1, 0)
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:24:28
well, yes, such things are tedious... but then we are at +5 now right?
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:24:48
I can send it if no one else wants to.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:25:02
!action nirik will send out the mail
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:25:04
Thank you.
<@siosm:fedora.im>
17:25:54
thanks
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:26:14
!topic #3693 removal of NetworkManager-{vpnc,fortisslvpn} in F43 and F44
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:26:20
!fesco 3693
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:26:21
**fesco/tickets #3693** (https://forge.fedoraproject.org/fesco/tickets/issues/3693):**removal of NetworkManager-{vpnc,fortisslvpn} in F43 and F44**
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:26:21
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:26:21
● **Opened:** a day ago by zbyszek
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:26:21
● **Last Updated:** 28 minutes ago
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:26:21
● **Assignee:** Not Assigned
<@siosm:fedora.im>
17:26:22
Do we want someone to reach out personnaly to the person that triggered this reminder?
<@zodbot:fedora.im>
17:26:47
siosm has already given cookies to kevin during the F44 timeframe
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:26:50
Oh, I forgot about this.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:26:55
Yeah, we should.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:27:32
nirik: can you also handle this?
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:27:49
hum? I'm not sure what the ask is?
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:28:07
we need to find someone to write the magazine article ?
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:28:07
To send a direct email to the packager.
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:28:20
which packager?
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:28:23
Sorry, this is for the previous topic.
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:28:30
lkundrak
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:28:37
oh, ok, thats why I was completely confused.
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:28:40
sure, I can
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:28:46
Thanks.
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:28:51
I had moved on to this new topic. ;)
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:28:54
OK, back to the actual topic.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:29:01
(apologies for the confusion)
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:29:04
oh... the person that triggered the provenpackager thing
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:29:10
got confused there
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:30:16
!info https://blogs.gnome.org/mcatanzaro/2026/09/15/privilege-escalation-vulnerabilities-in-networkmanager-plugins/
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:31:08
Yeah, so we need a volunteer to write the article. The blog would probably provide most of the introduction.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:31:22
Then there's the question of what the poor fedora users should do…
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:31:39
we don't really have good options here. scriptlet warning, obsoleting packages in a stable release, public blog post that loudly states Fedora has security issues all seem bad
<@siosm:fedora.im>
17:31:49
It would be good to remove those from systems given that the usage is likely very low, it's part of the default installation and users are exposed even if they don't user them. But apart from the Atomic Desktops, I don't know of a good way to do that.
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:31:53
I guess the blog post was the least problematic
<@siosm:fedora.im>
17:32:21
Blog is not bad to me, it's an honest announcement
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:32:44
yeah, if the solutions involve reconfuring a system we should nudge users to take manual action
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:32:49
I think it's an important step
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:33:55
I'd note that the ability to be able to trigger notification keeps coming up in different contexts, and that Debian/Ubuntu and openSUSE can both do this - so figuring out how to do that might be nice, separate from this particular incident
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:34:12
I guess we can reuse Michael's blog post and add a section about what users should specifically do to mitigate the problem (remove the package if it's not used, use a different supported plugin, etc.) and publish to Magazine
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:34:21
Does that sound reasonable?
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:34:27
Yes.
<@siosm:fedora.im>
17:35:11
yes. We need a volunteer
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:35:27
So Iet's do that. This isn't really a FESCo voting matter but rather needs to be coordinated with the Magazine editors
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:35:43
Maybe Michael wants to since he reported this?
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:35:53
we could ask
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:36:00
OK, let's try to figure this out in the ticket. Maybe somebody will volunteer.
<@siosm:fedora.im>
17:36:25
can we ack that I will remove those packages from the Atomic Desktops in F44?
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:36:44
I think that's reasonable.
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:36:57
+0
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:36:58
yeah, +1 there. as you note people that really really want them can layer them
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:37:00
I'd rather not remove the packages from stable release installs. that is pretty much the largest hammer we have and I think without precedent
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:37:13
but also we should mention that part... so perhaps that shouldn't happen until after the blog post
<@conan_kudo:matrix.org>
17:37:29
note that removal of plugins while NM has configuration for that is an untested mode
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:37:30
yep, after the blog post sounds good
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:37:33
I am willing to ack that you will do it but I would +0 on whether that's a good idea or not - on Workstation I'm -1
<@conan_kudo:matrix.org>
17:37:35
I have no idea what happens in that scenario
<@siosm:fedora.im>
17:37:56
The configuration is ignored?
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:38:02
well, it's not really removing them completely. it's just taking them out of the base layer...
<@conan_kudo:matrix.org>
17:38:18
I don't know what happens, and that is absolutely worth identifying
<@siosm:fedora.im>
17:38:32
It's not removed at runtime, it would apply on a reboot
<@conan_kudo:matrix.org>
17:38:37
if it results in NetworkManager being in a broken state when it can't autostart a config anymore, then that needs to be known
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:38:58
"no network after reboot" doesn't sound great
<@siosm:fedora.im>
17:38:58
That would be very surprising to me
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:39:04
In the past it's ignored. I know because I migrated a machine that had openvpn config without remembering to install the plugin. But this was a while ago
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:39:13
!info We're looking for a volunteer to write the Fedora Magazine article.
<@conan_kudo:matrix.org>
17:39:15
it would not surprise me at all
<@conan_kudo:matrix.org>
17:39:18
nobody thinks of these things
<@conan_kudo:matrix.org>
17:39:30
NM plugins die so rarely
<@siosm:fedora.im>
17:39:50
We did it for F45 in the Atomic Desktops already. Granted, it's still in beta
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:40:01
!info Those packages will be removed from the base layer of atomic installs, some time after the article has been published.
<@conan_kudo:matrix.org>
17:40:24
yes, but horrible breakages aren't great across the release boundary either
<@conan_kudo:matrix.org>
17:40:34
but at least we can warn people in release notes for them
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:40:54
well, sounds like some folks are against that? so we likely don't have votes to agree to that now do we ? Or are the folks with objections ok knowing that it's just removing from the base layer?
<@conan_kudo:matrix.org>
17:41:14
I'm not really in favor for removing them in F44 at all
<@conan_kudo:matrix.org>
17:41:19
not even in the atomics
<@conan_kudo:matrix.org>
17:41:47
but the upgrade situation with atomics is the same as the rebase situation, so 🤷♂️
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:42:27
I'm willing to do a weak +1 provided the article is out first and that the existing-config path is tested before removal
<@conan_kudo:matrix.org>
17:42:42
people need migration guidance for stuff like this, and the folks doing this obsoletion in F45 are the best folks to deal with that
<@conan_kudo:matrix.org>
17:42:45
indeed
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:43:13
OK, so let's discuss this when we have more info. It's likely that for the article the details of the transition would need to be figured out.
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:43:16
I don't really understand the base layer distinction. It's still removed when users update the base layer isn't it?
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:43:34
yes, but they can add it back with a overlay if they want it.
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:43:35
right, but they can layer it back in I think
<@siosm:fedora.im>
17:43:56
yes, it would be removed by default from all systems and they can add it back on demand
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:44:02
so as long as it does not crash anything (which Neal was worried about) they can fix themselves
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:44:09
so as long as it does not crash anything (which Neal was worried about) they can fix their machines
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:44:22
but that's the same thing as users can dnf install it again if we add obsoletes, no? it still requires manual intervention for users who still need the package
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:44:33
but anyway.. let's start with the blog post for now and go from there
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:44:40
if we add obsoletes users need to rebuild with a higher NEVRA and install, right?
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:44:44
well, depends on how the obsoletes are handled there I guess.
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:44:48
I think we can discuss any other steps after that in the ticket
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:44:53
Ack.
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:45:00
sure.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:45:13
!info Further steps will be discussed in the ticket.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:46:21
Fabio, typing?
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:46:28
I don't see that here fwiw
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:46:37
Matrix is weird
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:46:41
!topic Council happenings
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:46:42
I do see indicators when zbyszek is typing\
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:47:42
OK, let's wait a minute
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:47:49
I was not typing
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:47:56
at least not in this window :)
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:48:20
Ah, OK, so if you type in a different window, some clients show that as typing everywhere.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:48:33
Do you have something for us regarding the council?
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:48:44
I am on Wayland, that was supposed to fix keyboard stealers? :P
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:48:51
anyway, Council
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:49:13
the "conflict of interest" policy is now evolving into a "decision request support process" or whatever it's currently called
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:49:24
see discussion on discussion.fp.o
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:49:53
and we are currently figuring out the "themes" for Flock 2027. if anybody has any ideas?
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:50:11
!link Flock to Fedora 2027 CfP Themes Brainstorming https://forge.fedoraproject.org/council/tickets/issues/578
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:50:45
Do we know the location already?
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:50:59
no
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:51:24
we are also discussing whether logs of the history of the #council:fedoraproject.org channel should be made publicly available, but that still appears to be somewhat up in the air.
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:51:45
zbyszek: I only know "probably september or october" or something like that. maybe EU, maybe Schengen, maybe neither. or so.
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:52:07
~fin
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:52:56
ah, there was some discussion about adding a paragraph to the Council rep docs in the FESCo docs. please look at that proposal from Aoife.
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:53:12
was just going to ask about that...
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:53:20
link?
<@siosm:fedora.im>
17:53:48
https://forge.fedoraproject.org/fesco/tickets/issues/3613
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:54:03
proposal is in https://forge.fedoraproject.org/fesco/tickets/issues/3613#issuecomment-1363354
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:54:13
the comments after that are just confusion
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:54:31
(wikipedia says: The town of Schengen itself had a population of 711 as of September 2026. Finally we can swarm the location of Flock. ;) )
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:54:55
yeah, I have a hard time reading large walls of text these days... but it might be just me. ;)
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:54:56
I should have realized that every EU treaty is named after the town/city where it was signed
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:55:06
Maastricht, Bologna, Schengen...
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:55:36
same. I don't want to out people but ... man small texts are the worst now
<@siosm:fedora.im>
17:55:52
Jeff comments are mostly there to say that he can not comment unfortunately :/
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:56:14
anyhow... please vote on the proposed text if you haven't already
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:56:29
ack.
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:56:59
ack
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:57:00
the proposal text requires a "clear group voting strategy" for FESCo opinions on Council tickets. we have to decide what that means
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:57:06
sorry, where do we vote? I see a mention of a docs PR but it's not existing yet right
<@decathorpe:fedora.im>
17:57:42
yes, it would be easier if this was turned into a docs PR.
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:57:54
I think a lot of the underlying assumptions behind the comments on this ticket and the Council ticket about Matrix logging are wrong, but not sure what to do about that
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:58:06
I'm going to take this meeting from the train if it goes on more than another 15 mins fyi
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:58:08
I think Aoife Moloney wanted to get more feedback/consensus before submitting a docs pr?
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:58:14
I'm not sure why this is such a thing... we have a rep, they vote as best they can. If it is something they think will be contentious, they can say "sorry, I need to ask the rest of fesco what they think"
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
17:58:26
yeah, a pr would be nicer.
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:58:47
I stopped attending these because the whatabout-isms get so bad
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
17:58:58
attending what?
<@salimma:fedora.im>
17:59:06
discussions about all these
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:59:18
Anyhoo, I'll move to open floor in a minute. Last chance to quickly comment here.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
17:59:39
!topic Open Floor
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
18:00:17
I want to say that Aoifee sent out a bunch of change announcements before our meeting. Some are very intresting.
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
18:01:07
we still have a number of blockerbugs... do help out if you can with any in your areas. https://qa.fedoraproject.org/blockerbugs/milestone/45/final/buglist
<@salimma:fedora.im>
18:01:09
I think we need to sync up and ask for these to be sent out on Mondays
<@salimma:fedora.im>
18:01:32
technically we should even send out the meeting agenda on Mondays too, but it's also really hard when these changes are sent out late
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
18:01:34
hum? I would think they should be sent when ready?
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
18:01:34
I need to take a closer look at the dnf4 change. I support getting rid of modularity libraries asap and eventually getting rid of python3-dnf, but we have a lot of releng stuff that still relies on python3-dnf
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
18:01:59
they are often sent in a batch on Tuesdays
<@salimma:fedora.im>
18:02:23
right. sending them on Tuesdays means mentioning them in the meeting is ... a bit rushed, so it's kind of like just missing the train
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
18:02:24
sure, but I am not sure it really matters... the f46 deadlines are... far from now. No great hurry.
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
18:03:05
yeah, I don't think the Tuesday announcements are a huge deal
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
18:03:24
especially that we're not actually discussing these in fesco yet, only in the community discussion on the list
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
18:03:31
especially considering that we're not actually discussing these in fesco yet, only in the community discussion on the list
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
18:03:37
For announcements, this doesn't matter so much. OTOH, the fesco votes matter, for those we want the week of voting to finish before Tuesday morning when the agenda is typically sent out.
<@salimma:fedora.im>
18:04:10
yeah but ... per our meeting procedures, we're supposed to send the agenda out on Monday, no?
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
18:04:31
for the libical Change that is currently in FESCo, I noted that we may need a shepherd or provenpackager on the Change since it involves a mass rebuild
<@salimma:fedora.im>
18:04:45
https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/FESCo_meeting_process <-- "one day before"
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
18:05:03
does anyone in a European timezone want to volunteer? otherwise, I can try to help, but my availability is somewhat limited
<@gotmax23:fedora.im>
18:05:34
does anyone in a European timezone want to volunteer (that's where the Change Owner is, I think)? otherwise, I can try to help, but my availability is somewhat limited
<@salimma:fedora.im>
18:05:45
I can help if needed
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
18:05:47
yeah, I would sure love a day before... when sent tuesday morning it's when I am asleep so I only get it at the last minute.
<@salimma:fedora.im>
18:06:28
I agree it's not a big deal, but as someone mentioned allowing a one week vote, it will align nicely if the changes are pushed out one day earlier :)
<@salimma:fedora.im>
18:06:39
ok, starting to pack to go home
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
18:07:11
OK, anything else for the Open Floor?
<@nirik:matrix.scrye.com>
18:07:22
nothing here.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
18:07:41
I'll close in a minute.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
18:07:47
Thank you all for coming.
<@zbyszek:fedora.im>
18:08:06
!endmeeting