AGREED: 1592686 -
RejectedBlocker (Beta) - this only affects passworded VNC, and the
criterion doesn't require that to work, just 'VNC'. which does
work(adamw,
17:12:34)
(1596540) RuntimeError: C++ std::exception: Exec failed: no such table: main.trans_cmdline(adamw, 17:12:44)
AGREED: 1596540 -
RejectedBlocker (Beta) - we're all sort of worried about dnf in
general and a little about this bug in particular, but as lots of
people *didn't* hit it and no-one has found a clear reproducer yet,
we don't feel like we can reasonably count it as a blocker at this
point(adamw,
17:28:58)
(1625259) RuntimeError: TransactionItem not found for key(adamw, 17:29:53)
AGREED: 1625259 -
RejectedBlocker (Beta) - again this is quite worrying, but with
careful analysis of zbyszek's case, we still don't believe this is
affecting 'normal', criteria-covered operations, only downgrades and
possibly cases where the RPM database has existing duplicate
entries(adamw,
17:39:01)
(1628525) F29 KDE Live contains old wallpaper from F28(adamw, 17:39:59)
AGREED: 1626932 -
RejectedBlocker (Beta) - the state of this issue with Beta RC1 as
described in comment #7 clearly doesn't violate any criteria(adamw,
17:56:27)
(1628497) gnome-software shows upgrade banner for Fedora 28 instead of Fedora 29(adamw, 17:56:45)
AGREED: 1628497 -
RejectedBlocker (Beta), AcceptedPreviousReleaseBlocker (Final) - as
there are viable workarounds (use dnf, go through F28 first, hack up
the cached JSON...) we believe those are sufficient for Beta, but
this counts as a violation of the upgrade criterion for Final and
must be fixed in F27 prior to F29 release(adamw,
18:21:22)
(1628192) Fedora 29 installation cannot see a firmware RAID device.(adamw, 18:21:45)
AGREED: 1628192 -
RejectedBlocker (Beta) AcceptedFreezeException (Beta) - this is a
fairly clear violation of the criteria as written (though with a
workaround), but there is substantial support for either moving the
firmware RAID criterion to Final or removing it entirely. On that
basis this is rejected as a blocker, and we will send some criteria
proposals to the list, expecting at least that the Beta requirement
will no longer exist.(adamw,
18:38:32)
now doing the sole accepted blocker before
circling back to the KDE backgrounds thing(adamw,
18:39:00)
(1628355) F29 Beta RC1 does not boot on Raspberry Pi(adamw, 18:39:09)
this bug meant Beta RC1 32-bit ARM images do
not boot on Raspberry Pi. Pi2 and Pi3 are supported platforms. Beta
RC2 should fix this, but it is still composing at present and so has
not been tested at all yet.(adamw,
18:41:34)
circling back to KDE backgrounds blocker(adamw,
18:41:48)
(1628525) F29 KDE Live contains old wallpaper from F28(adamw, 18:42:01)
AGREED: 1628525 -
AcceptedFreezeException (Beta) - we do not have a clear vote on
blocker status for this bug (the vote was +4, -3). but we have
consensus that it should at least be a freeze exception. we will
proceed with the meeting with its blocker status undecided(adamw,
18:53:14)
validation coverage is actually pretty good for
RC1 (which still has the known ARM blocker). I see only a couple of
missing tests (hardware RAID, 'basic audio'). There is no validation
coverage at all for RC2 yet. Difference between RC1 and RC2 is
minimal so we could consider most RC1 testing valid against RC2, but
we should really at least smoke-test RC2 and check the ARM images
boot on rasbpi(adamw,
18:56:04)