Purpose of this meeting is to check whether or
not F27 Final and F27 Server Beta are ready for shipment, according
to the release criteria.(jkurik,
17:02:55)
This is determined in a few ways:(jkurik,
17:03:01)
* Release candidate compose is available(jkurik,
17:03:07)
AGREED: 1505090 -
RejectedBlocker (Final) AcceptedFreezeException (Final) - so far as
we understand this, as it involves source selection, is specific to
text mode and can be worked around by tweaking the package selection
it is not a blocker, but we grant FE status as it's an installer
issue that can't be fixed with an update(adamw,
17:31:59)
(1506479) unable to boot into the former existing system after do another shrink installation(adamw, 17:32:07)
AGREED: 1506479 -
RejectedBlocker (Final) - this involves a scenario (dual-install of
two Fedora 27 flavors) which is not covered by the release criteria
at all, therefore rejected(adamw,
17:38:38)
(1506509) workstation system is out of network when double installed with server system(adamw, 17:38:46)
AGREED: 1506509 -
RejectedBlocker (Final) - this involves a scenario (dual-install of
two Fedora 27 flavors) which is not covered by the release criteria
at all, therefore rejected(adamw,
17:42:59)
(1504059) Include Firefox 57 at compose(adamw, 17:43:05)
AGREED: 1495509 -
RejectedBlocker AcceptedFreezeException (Final) - this is rejected
as a blocker: it only occurs when no network connection is
available, and we think that makes it not important enough to block
the release. however we grant an FE as it would still be nice to
avoid such crashes in live and freshly-installed systems if
possible, but we will only push a fix if it seems fairly small and
safe(adamw,
18:06:30)
(1506052) Package build of official release notes required for Fedora 27 Final(adamw, 18:06:45)
AGREED: 1506052 -
AcceptedBlocker (Final) - there's a bit of a backstory about exactly
what we want to require with regard to release notes, but at least
the inclusion of outdated release notes in the repos and some media
is clearly against both the existing criterion and our
generally-agreed intent, so this is accepted as a blocker(adamw,
18:21:41)
(1505906) Disable f27 updates testing repo for F27 final(adamw, 18:21:54)
AGREED: 1505906 -
AcceptedBlocker (Final) - this is a clear violation of "A
fedora-release package containing the correct names, information and
repository configuration for a final Fedora release must be present
on release-blocking images and the appropriately versioned
generic-release package must be available in the release
repository"(adamw,
18:27:14)
(1496489) After upgrading to Fedora 27: Failed to Update - Too many results returned(adamw, 18:28:31)
AGREED: 1496489 -
RejectedBlocker AcceptedFreezeException (Final) - this doesn't
actually break the upgrade process so it doesn't constitute a
blocker, but we think it's worth an FE just to avoid the issue
hitting people who upgrade before the 0-day update push(adamw,
18:31:50)
(1506050) spin-kickstarts package build needed for Fedora 27 final(adamw, 18:31:56)
AGREED: 1506050 -
AcceptedBlocker (Final) - clear violation of "A spin-kickstarts
package which contains the exact kickstart files used to build the
release must be present in the release repository. The included
kickstarts must define the correct set of release
repositories."(adamw,
18:38:35)
we have a couple of proposed Final freeze
exceptions(adamw,
18:39:03)
(1471401) SELinux is preventing systemd from read, write access on the chr_file /dev/input/event9.(adamw, 18:39:13)
AGREED: 1499170 -
AcceptedFreezeException (Final) - the impact of this is quite bad
for a specific subset of users, can't be fixed with an update as it
affects initial install and boot, and the fix should be safe as it
will be an SELinux policy loosening(adamw,
18:55:24)
AGREED: Due to
missing RC for the F27 Server Beta release the decision is “No Go”.
The F27 Server Beta release slips for one week. F27 Server Final GA
date slip to the Final Rain date 2017-Dec-19.(jkurik,
19:06:46)
AGREED: Due to
missing RC for the F27 Final release the decision is “No Go”. The GA
date for the F27 Final release moves from Target date to Rain date,
which is 2017-Nov-07.(jkurik,
19:08:44)
ACTION: jkurik to
publish the Go/No-Go result(jkurik,
19:08:53)
ACTION: jkurik to
organize the Go/No-Go meeting on Thursday, November 2nd at
17:00UTC(jkurik,
19:09:08)