Our purpose in this meeting is to review
proposed blocker and nice-to-have bugs and decide whether to accept
them, and to monitor the progress of fixing existing accepted
blocker and nice-to-have bugs.(adamw,
16:04:34)
We'll be following the process outlined
at:(adamw,
16:04:34)
AGREED: 1337731 -
conditional AcceptedBlocker (Final) - the dnf update is not yet
stable, but there seems to be a possibility that it will be pushed
stable. If it does go stable with no fix for this bug in any other
component, this bug can be marked as an AcceptedBlocker due to
obvious violation of criteria by preventing release-blocking images
from composing(adamw,
16:16:09)
(1336810) Calligra Words crashed when I opened a template.(adamw, 16:16:17)
AGREED: 1336810 -
AcceptedBlocker (Final) - clear violation of cited criterion "All
applications that can be launched using the standard graphical
mechanism of a release-blocking desktop after a default installation
of that desktop must start successfully and withstand a basic
functionality test."(adamw,
16:22:12)
(1336879) dnf fails to respect conditional level in comps.xml(adamw, 16:22:22)
AGREED: 1336879 -
RejectedBlocker, RejectedFreezeException (Final) - none of the known
impacts of this appear to violate the release criteria, and any
missing packages on deliverables can be resolved by adding them to
spin-kickstarts until this bug is dealt with. We also think changing
this after freeze would be too dangerous for too little
benefit(adamw,
16:36:00)
AGREED: 1337336 -
punt (delay decision) - this is definitely a worrying bug but we
want to be clear on the circumstances in which it does and does not
occur before making a final decision(adamw,
16:48:38)
(1338054) Fedora 24 keepassx has a lower version number it wants to upgrade a higher version package from Fedora 23(adamw, 16:48:47)
AGREED: 1338054 -
RejectedBlocker AcceptedFreezeException (Final) - this is definitely
a mess but keepassx is not in any of the package sets cited in the
criteria, so it does not qualify as a release blocker. It's accepted
as a freeze exception issue as upgrades usually run with u-t
disabled, so there is a benefit to pushing it stable between freeze
date and 0-day update push date(adamw,
16:56:31)
(1337582) Fails to start with "Cannot read MSR_ERROR_CONTROL from /dev/cpu/0/msr" when running in VM on Xeon E5-2450 host(adamw, 16:57:05)
AGREED: 1337582 -
punt (delay decision) - we're inclined to think this is likely too
hardware-specific to be a blocker, but we'd like to get some
thoughts from mcelog packager/developers if possible, so delaying
the decision to see if we hear from them(adamw,
17:05:29)
(1332266) systemd-logind does not verify if system has resume device defined when checking if can.hibernate or can.hybridsleep(adamw, 17:05:44)
AGREED: 1332266 -
RejectedBlocker AcceptedFreezeException (Final) - we think the
consequences of this are unfortunate but don't really constitute a
violation of the criteria, the 'data loss' scenario is quite
contrived and there is strong precedent to not considering
suspend/hibernate issues as release-blocking. This is definitely
significant enough to constitute a freeze exception issue,
however(adamw,
17:22:59)
there hasn't been a lot of movement in terms of
fixing this bug, but some further testing suggests it may not be as
clearly reproducible as first thought, we may consider re-evaluating
it later(adamw,
17:43:53)
(1333106) Server deployment fails due to SELinux policy changes on current Fedora Rawhide and F24 (2016-05-21)(adamw, 17:44:01)