15:05:50 <trown> #startmeeting RDO meeting (2015-10-21)
15:05:50 <zodbot> Meeting started Wed Oct 21 15:05:50 2015 UTC.  The chair is trown. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
15:05:50 <zodbot> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #halp #info #idea #link #topic.
15:05:58 <number80> o/
15:06:01 <apevec> o/
15:06:08 <jpena> o/
15:06:15 <apevec> #halp ?
15:06:18 <rbowen> I'm actually in a meeting at the mother ship today, so I'm here, but not very attentive.
15:06:24 <trown> #chair number80 apevec jpena rbowen
15:06:24 <zodbot> Current chairs: apevec jpena number80 rbowen trown
15:06:36 <apevec> rbowen, np, you'll get all AIs :)
15:06:44 <rbowen> yep. :-)
15:06:55 <trown> hehe
15:07:06 <dtantsur> o/
15:07:13 <trown> #chair dtantsur
15:07:13 <zodbot> Current chairs: apevec dtantsur jpena number80 rbowen trown
15:07:45 <trown> ok lets get started
15:07:51 <trown> #topic AI reports
15:07:52 * social o/
15:08:01 <trown> #chair social
15:08:01 <zodbot> Current chairs: apevec dtantsur jpena number80 rbowen social trown
15:08:08 <apevec> trown, ah that's actually not a topic
15:08:13 <apevec> it should be just FYI in agenda
15:08:35 <apevec> but looks like only recorded AI last time was that you's chairing today
15:08:37 <trown> oh ok, so folks with AI from last meeting should update the etherpad?
15:08:54 <apevec> yeah, so we don't loose time on it
15:09:06 <trown> #link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/RDO-Packaging
15:09:07 <trown> ack
15:09:16 <apevec> I'll get that written
15:09:26 <trown> #topic Any RDO Liberty GA blockers?
15:09:37 <dtantsur> did you update inspector?
15:09:38 <apevec> #action apevec explain "AI reports" in agenda
15:09:44 <apevec> dtantsur, yes
15:09:48 <trown> dtantsur: yep inspector is updated
15:09:49 <dtantsur> awesome, thanks
15:09:56 <apevec> ready in -release I just wanted someone to verify the build
15:10:30 <trown> apevec: ya there are a couple folks verifying https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1273680#c11 and I asked to make sure they have the updated inspector as well
15:10:34 <apevec> #link http://cbs.centos.org/koji/buildinfo?buildID=7094 openstack-ironic-inspector-2.2.2-1.el7
15:10:38 <apevec> dtantsur, ^
15:10:56 <dmsimard> o/ (sorry late)
15:11:00 <apevec> trown, lemme check if it was mirrored to buildlogs
15:11:15 <trown> which is the first item here. I think https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1273680 was a side effect of RDO_RELEASE not working properly and should not be a blocker
15:11:18 <number80> I applied EmilienM aodh group permissions fix on aodh
15:11:24 <trown> #chair dmsimard
15:11:24 <zodbot> Current chairs: apevec dmsimard dtantsur jpena number80 rbowen social trown
15:11:47 <number80> https://github.com/openstack-packages/aodh/commit/b25f8dc1fb480fa51281a48b1e0d3704b85399b2
15:12:00 <number80> http://cbs.centos.org/koji/buildinfo?buildID=7093
15:12:13 <apevec> number80, how can we verify if that's all for aodh ?
15:12:36 <dmsimard> apevec, number80: there's smoke running *right now* for both rdo manager and packstack on a repo with the aodh fixes in
15:12:52 <number80> apevec: unless there's another issue, aodh perms are fixed now
15:12:55 <apevec> dmsimard, but does smoke cover aodh?
15:12:56 <dmsimard> However, there are no smoke tests for aodh (EmilienM actually tried to put some upstream but got rejected)
15:13:14 <apevec> afaik aodh is not event installed by either packstack or mgr ?
15:13:17 <dmsimard> apevec: EmilienM came across the aodh issues when packaging a puppet module for aodh and doing it's acceptance tests
15:13:29 <dmsimard> apevec: correct, afaik
15:13:42 <number80> that's why it's not a blocker for GA
15:13:51 <trown> what is aodh?
15:13:52 <number80> it's nice to have
15:13:56 <apevec> so real test is to ask EmilienM to try it but he needs passed-ci first...
15:13:58 <apevec> number80, ack
15:14:03 <number80> trown: alarm code splitted from ceilometer
15:14:04 <apevec> trown, part of ceilo
15:14:05 <dmsimard> trown: aodh is a spinoff off of ceilometer to manage alamring
15:14:07 <trown> ah ok
15:14:19 <EmilienM> hello
15:14:21 <rook> trown: installed the latest liberty RPM and the repo points here : http://buildlogs.centos.org/centos/7Server/cloud/x86_64/openstack-liberty/repodata/repomd.xml
15:14:21 <jruzicka> o/
15:14:24 <dmsimard> ceilometer, gnocchi and aodh now
15:14:25 <dmsimard> fun
15:14:31 <number80> a true blocker is trove configuration
15:14:35 <rook> whcih provides a 404
15:14:35 <apevec> rook, yep
15:14:38 <number80> *file broken
15:14:45 <rook> apevec: expected?
15:14:47 <apevec> rook, 404 /
15:14:49 <apevec> ?
15:14:52 <dmsimard> number80: what trove config ?
15:15:08 <rook> apevec welll "Not Found"
15:15:13 <number80> dmsimard: it was reported here, the config files we ship are broken
15:15:18 <apevec> rook, oh crap is that RHEL ?
15:15:27 <apevec> 7Server
15:15:29 <rook> apevec: yes... trown warned me
15:15:30 <sasha21> trown: I continuously run into https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1271289
15:15:39 <sasha21> trown: https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1271289#c6 works for me as w/a
15:15:41 <trown> rook: I did warn you :P
15:15:44 <rook> haha
15:15:44 <number80> I would have pushed it earlier but I have to sync branches of the package first
15:15:46 <apevec> rook, yeah only centos7 is tested, but I'll fix that
15:15:50 <rook> didn't even get out of the damn gate.
15:16:00 <apevec> rook, please file me issue in
15:16:00 <rook> apevec: roger yeah, I want to try rhel -- hope rhel71 suffices.
15:16:04 <sasha21> trown: how come I get 2 mac addresses after the introspection
15:16:12 <apevec> https://github.com/redhat-openstack/rdo-release
15:16:14 <trown> dtantsur: ^
15:16:19 <apevec> rook, ^
15:16:25 <apevec> https://github.com/redhat-openstack/rdo-release/issues
15:16:37 <dtantsur> sasha21, vm/baremetal?
15:16:42 <sasha21> dtantsur: bm
15:16:55 <apevec> #action apevec fix rdo-release-liberty.rpm for rhel
15:17:01 <dtantsur> sasha21, could you paste your /etc/ironic-inspector/inspector.conf?
15:17:12 <rbowen> We need to have a better front end to "where does this ticket go" on the RDO site.
15:17:21 <apevec> rook, yeah, 7.1 should work, it will just need few non-default repos enabled
15:17:49 <dmsimard> rbowen: +1, where to file bugs would be helpful - or at least have some default bin somewhere where we can have knowledgeable members triage
15:17:54 <sasha21> dtantsur: http://fpaste.org/281959/44544064/
15:18:09 <sasha21> dtantsur: so I always remove the second mac from nodes and re-attempt deployment
15:18:14 <trown> ok we are a bit off topic... what is the AI for trove blocker
15:18:15 <apevec> dtantsur, trown - in the meantime inspector 2.2.2 landed in http://buildlogs.centos.org/centos/7/cloud/x86_64/openstack-liberty/?C=M;O=D
15:18:43 <rook> apevec roger . https://github.com/redhat-openstack/rdo-release/issues/2
15:19:26 <Goneri> I do some test with RDO Liberty and get this error: https://paste.fedoraproject.org/281961/14454407/ I'm not sure if Khaleesi should adjust the $PATH of If we should patch instack-undercloud (that's what I did https://review.openstack.org/#/c/238069/ ).
15:19:31 <apevec> trown, number80, oh we don't have trove GA build yet?
15:19:46 <apevec> now I see we have openstack-trove-4.0.0-0.1.0rc2.el7 in testing
15:20:02 <number80> apevec: nope
15:20:03 <apevec> I'll untag it, it is not installed by either packstack or mgr, is it?
15:20:18 <trown> Goneri: I can help you with that after the meeting
15:20:24 <number80> it'll be done tonight
15:20:27 <chandankumar_awa> o/
15:20:36 <apevec> number80, ok then it will be pushed after GA
15:20:39 <dtantsur> sasha21, looks good, now `sudo journalctl -u openstack-ironic-inspector` please
15:20:40 <trown> Goneri: it is a khaleesi issue
15:20:48 <number80> apevec: ack
15:21:03 <trown> #chair chandankumar
15:21:03 <zodbot> Current chairs: apevec chandankumar dmsimard dtantsur jpena number80 rbowen social trown
15:21:05 <apevec> if no blockers are reported NOW, I'd like to be as close as possible to traditional noon EST deadline
15:21:06 <Goneri> trown, thanks, i close the review. Sorry if I come in a middle of a meeting.
15:22:10 <trown> apevec: manager does not install trove
15:22:30 <rook> apevec ill hold off for now - do we think the repo will be alive later today/this week
15:22:32 <apevec> ok, trove rc2 is untagged and won't be pushed for GA
15:22:44 <apevec> rook, GA will be today
15:23:00 <rook> apevec so the RHEL7 repos will be live too ?
15:23:01 <apevec> rook, but content is the same as current testing
15:23:04 <rook> right
15:23:08 <apevec> it's the same repo
15:23:12 <rook> ah ok
15:23:13 <apevec> I just need fixe release rpm
15:23:17 <rook> rgr
15:23:30 <apevec> silly RHELisms
15:23:45 <trown> is there anything needed for: announcement text based on https://wiki.centos.org/SpecialInterestGroup/AnnouncingReleases
15:23:54 <sasha21> dtantsur: http://fpaste.org/281963/44544099/
15:24:15 <apevec> I mean, $releasever = 7Server - what were they thinking??
15:24:36 <apevec> trown, yes. Needs to be written :)
15:24:40 <trown> lol
15:24:51 <trown> is that AI on rbowen?
15:24:53 <apevec> rbowen, ^ can you take that or tied up w/ allday meetings?
15:25:11 <apevec> yeah, but looks like he might not be able to do it
15:25:11 <dtantsur> sasha21, this looks incomplete, is it really the full log? anyway, let's move it to #tripleo to not interfere with the meeting
15:25:21 <rbowen> Sending out the announce? Yes, I can do that.
15:25:30 <apevec> rbowen, no, writing it :)
15:25:42 <sasha21> dtantsur: meeting?
15:25:47 <rbowen> Oh, writing it. I'd like to pass that on. I'm needing to be very focused here.
15:26:09 <apevec> rbowen, ok I'll put up a draft and send around for quick reviews
15:26:10 <dtantsur> sasha21, the RDO meeting that is going on around us right now right here :)
15:26:22 <trown> apevec++
15:26:24 <apevec> rbowen, just advice re "branding"
15:26:40 <apevec> in the light of recent release rpm discussion
15:27:00 <trown> #action apevec to draft release announcement and post back for quick reviews
15:27:01 <apevec> rbowen, Can we have one announcement which works for both cloud sig and RDO ?
15:27:30 <apevec> I'll try my best, but notorious as brand-ignorant :)
15:27:46 <rbowen> Yes, I think so, if it doesn't further contribute to the confusion that we already have about CentOS/RDO/Delorean and what each one is.
15:28:03 <rbowen> Apparently we need to do a better job of communicating what each of those is.
15:28:30 <apevec> folks put too much into names, it's all just tools for the job
15:29:02 <apevec> anyway, I'll try my best, feedback will be welcome
15:29:14 <rbowen> Sure. But if we don't tell people which tool is for which job, they'll start hammering the screws. :-)
15:29:35 <csim> ah ah
15:29:49 <apevec> rbowen, that's sometimes needed actually, but got it :)
15:30:07 <trown> ok are we good on RDO Liberty GA topic?
15:30:07 <rbowen> :)
15:30:11 <apevec> I'll few words w/ definitions
15:30:17 <apevec> s/few/add few/
15:30:37 <apevec> trown, yes, just to confirm: no new known blockers ?
15:31:04 <apevec> and I can ping KB after this meeting to start sync to mirros ?
15:31:23 <apevec> warning: silence means YES
15:32:04 <apevec> then...
15:32:05 <trown> apevec: not that I have seen, there is still verification in progress for https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1273680
15:32:19 <trown> but I am convinced that is the RDO_RELEASE issue
15:32:24 <apevec> #action apevec ping KB after the meeting to start sync to mirros
15:32:42 <apevec> trown, yep afaict that was it
15:32:50 <trown> ok moving on
15:32:57 <trown> #topic Package Reviews
15:32:58 <apevec> trown, one thing re docs
15:33:11 <apevec> trown, is it updated to use rdo-release-liberty.rpm everywhere now?
15:33:37 <trown> apevec: no I need to do that after the meeting, only instructions for manager are delorean based
15:34:08 <trown> #action trown update rdo manager docs for rdo-release-liberty.rpm
15:34:27 <apevec> back to topic, package reviews
15:34:48 <apevec> we had few contributed last week, but not reviewers yet...
15:35:07 <apevec> is someone interested ?
15:35:19 <apevec> for grabs are murano mistral and ec2 api
15:35:33 <trown> these are fedora reviews?
15:35:37 <number80> nope
15:35:40 <apevec> RDO
15:35:42 <trown> ok
15:35:48 <number80> mistral is available
15:35:51 <apevec> but clients are for fedora
15:36:42 <trown> I do not think I can take anything else on until after Summit, but if they are still untaken then, I would not mind
15:37:26 <apevec> links to review BZs were posted in [Rdo-list] Review of Murano, Mistral, python-muranoclient, python-mistralclient
15:37:56 <apevec> ok, I'll also start grabbing some tomorrow after GA is cleared
15:38:15 <apevec> but please anyone start doing package reviews it's fun!
15:38:16 <apevec> :)
15:38:22 <dmsimard> trown: smoke is green for me
15:38:27 <number80> +2
15:38:31 <apevec> even if you're not Fedora packager yet
15:38:39 <number80> moreover, if you're unsure, just do an informal one
15:38:40 <apevec> informal reviews are counted
15:38:47 <apevec> when trying to join packagers
15:38:50 <number80> it helps reducing the lead time
15:38:53 <apevec> yep
15:39:39 <jschlueter> where is starting point for reviewer?
15:39:44 <apevec> number80, maybe we could create separate repos for informal reviewing in gerrit?
15:40:04 <apevec> jschlueter, fedora guidelines, RDO inherits them
15:40:15 <apevec> we just can do (unwritten yet) exceptions
15:40:20 <jschlueter> I'm interested in being informal reviewer when I have spare cycles
15:40:31 <apevec> number80 has initial draft in trello
15:40:51 <apevec> jschlueter, one comment in https://trello.com/c/7WaR9j3X/81-bugzilla-component-for-packages-reviews
15:41:10 <apevec> NB https://bugzilla.redhat.com/enter_bug.cgi?product=RDO&format=fedora-review does NOT work yet
15:41:33 <apevec> but you can use template with product=Fedora then change it
15:41:53 <trown> ok moving on?
15:42:03 <apevec> this all should be in updates to rdo-packaging (coming soon after GA!)
15:42:05 <apevec> trown, yes
15:42:08 <trown> #topic Delorean server rebuild (after Summit)
15:42:34 <dmsimard> jpena: ^
15:43:03 <jpena> This is just a heads up: we are planning to rebuild the Delorean instance to get some bigger specs, use mock to build and update the user-data
15:43:05 <apevec> this will be switch to mock and larger flavour?
15:43:10 <apevec> ok
15:43:26 <jpena> this will happen the week after summit, I'll send an announcement on rdo-list when the plan is finished
15:43:30 <apevec> jpena, see in agenda, I'd like one fix cherry picked into production before that
15:43:44 <jpena> apevec: no problem, I'll do that after the meeting
15:43:51 <apevec> opm has bad NEVR now
15:43:54 <apevec> ok, thanks!
15:44:09 <jpena> #action jpena to cherry pick http://rdoproject.org/repos/openstack-liberty/rdo-release-liberty.rpm into production delorean
15:44:14 <jpena> #undo
15:44:14 <zodbot> Removing item from minutes: ACTION by jpena at 15:44:09 : jpena to cherry pick http://rdoproject.org/repos/openstack-liberty/rdo-release-liberty.rpm into production delorean
15:44:29 <apevec> wrong paste? :)
15:44:43 <jpena> #action jpena to cherry pick https://github.com/openstack-packages/delorean/commit/dbd4271b23cf50d0f68768af5d33905be55aec38 into production delorean
15:44:48 <jpena> :o)
15:45:13 <apevec> be careful with that paste, could've been password
15:45:36 <apevec> we're done with the agenda!
15:45:47 <trown> #topic open floor
15:47:10 <dmsimard> Don't forget the RDO community lunch in Tokyo
15:47:19 <dmsimard> You're all invited
15:47:35 <trown> dmsimard: when is that
15:47:46 <dmsimard> http://openstacksummitoctober2015tokyo.sched.org/event/3f4fc45fd4e9ee0a0a02749f97a67499
15:47:52 <dmsimard> #link http://openstacksummitoctober2015tokyo.sched.org/event/3f4fc45fd4e9ee0a0a02749f97a67499
15:47:59 <trown> awesome thanks
15:48:39 <trown> ok seems like we can close out the meeting
15:48:40 <apevec> yeah, what time is 1500 UTC in Tokyo next week?
15:48:48 <trown> oh... right
15:49:00 <apevec> i.e. who will be around for the meeting next week except me :)
15:49:03 <trown> #topic chair for next meeting?
15:49:09 <apevec> I'll take it
15:49:13 <trown> lol
15:49:16 <dmsimard> apevec: looks like around midnight
15:49:20 <dmsimard> https://www.google.ca/?gfe_rd=cr&ei=7LMnVuz9MoSJMcasiqAB&gws_rd=ssl#safe=off&q=3pm+utc+in+tokyo
15:49:21 <apevec> to meet me myself and I
15:49:34 <trown> #action apevec to chair next meeting
15:49:36 <dmsimard> I ... probably won't attend the next meeting :p
15:49:44 <apevec> dmsimard, you'll be all drinking sake at that time
15:49:55 <number80> or shoshu
15:49:58 <trown> apevec: the tricky part is if nobody is here you will have no one to take the meeting after next :p
15:50:10 <apevec> crap :)
15:50:24 <dmsimard> lmao
15:50:34 <trown> thanks everyone for attending!
15:50:37 <trown> #endmeeting