19:00:09 #startmeeting 19:00:09 Meeting started Tue Jul 20 19:00:09 2010 UTC. The chair is mizmo. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 19:00:09 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #halp #info #idea #link #topic. 19:00:14 #topic roll call! 19:00:19 * mizmo Máirín Duffy here 19:00:24 * nicubunu here 19:00:28 * Schendje here 19:00:33 this is like flight of the conchords... lol.... present 19:00:34 o/ 19:01:09 * sijis is around 19:01:09 * mbenitez hello 19:01:31 yay looks like we've got a decent turnout 19:01:33 aiight 19:01:37 lets move on to our first topic 19:01:46 #topic F14 artwork feedback 19:01:59 so kylebaker setup a wiki page to gather feedback 19:02:06 https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/F14_Artwork_Feedback 19:02:32 I blogged it and it got carried by a bunch of 3rd party sites including linuxtoday https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/F14_Artwork_Feedback#External_References 19:02:40 nice :) 19:03:03 Schendje posted it to the users list and we got a good thread going there too http://lists.fedoraproject.org/pipermail/users/2010-July/377900.html 19:03:10 Schendje, did you get a chance to post it to fedoraforum.org as well? 19:03:20 oops, no 19:03:25 ryanlerch, did you notice any good identi.ca or twitter feedback? 19:03:25 i thought finalzone would do that actually :( 19:03:29 Schendje, ahh okay 19:03:33 cause he's a mod or admin there 19:03:34 oh he isn't around 19:03:36 yeh thats right 19:03:39 i don't even have an account 19:04:01 #action okay, ill update the fedoraforum F14 feedback task to have finalzone's name and ill email him on it 19:04:15 must confess that i also haven't added the feedback from the users ML to the wiki page (yet) 19:04:22 i'll do that tomorrow or so :) 19:04:37 it's all good, i still have to update the latest comments from my blog post on there 19:04:39 mostly though it's generally the same as what's already on the wiki (which i guess is a good thing) 19:04:48 #action Schendje to copy over users list feedback onto the wiki page at https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/F14_Artwork_Feedback 19:04:58 #action mizmo to update blog post feedback on https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/F14_Artwork_Feedback 19:05:14 yeh the most common feedback i see is 'too dark' 19:05:22 lol yeah 19:05:26 does anybody else have ideas on where we should seek out feedback 19:05:29 dark rocks 19:05:32 or has anybody heard any feedback in other venues? 19:05:41 the dark side is always the most interesting ;) 19:05:50 lol 19:05:56 aiight well let's move on to the next topic then 19:06:10 #topic F14 artwork - has anyone made any progess on our winning alpha concept yet? 19:06:17 has anybody poked at the F14 artwork for alpha yet? 19:06:22 we're getting short on time, I think just one more week 19:06:28 the deadline for alpha is jul 27 19:06:45 not me, though i want to 19:06:49 for reference the URL is here, which has links to the sources https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/F14_Artwork_Theme_Concepts 19:06:50 haven't found the time 19:07:16 it's definitely not the end of the world if we ship as-is in alpha but it would be nice to get some iteration in there 19:07:27 can anyone commit to playing around with it by next tuesday? 19:07:43 and presenting your work at next tuesday's meeting? 19:07:49 i can have a look 19:07:54 fabsh, sweet! 19:07:56 cant promise anything tho 19:07:59 i will, but can't promise it'll look good :D 19:08:00 ideally the work is presented on the list 19:08:01 fabsh, you can't commit? 19:08:07 so other have time to play with it 19:08:09 the thing is we have a deadline.... 19:08:12 i can commit to doing something 19:08:23 nicubunu, yeh thats true, iterations should be posted to the mailing list first 19:08:24 all along 19:08:24 not sure it will be good though... ;) 19:08:35 fabsh, ah okay i get your meaning now :) 19:08:37 cool 19:09:03 i'll have a poke at it 19:09:09 #action fabsh & Schendje to iterate on F14 artwork for alpha and post what they come up with to the list before jul 27 meeting https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/F14_Artwork_Theme_Concepts 19:09:15 and i'll mail that to the list too 19:09:27 sweet thanks fabsh and Schendje :) 19:09:36 okay we'll move on to the next topic 19:09:43 #topic Fedora branding font - any more feedback on Comfortaa, Cantarell, or Droid Sans? 19:09:54 i have one q on comfortaa 19:10:01 one piece of news I have, Johan emailed me this morning, and he said he's officially changed Comfortaa's license to OFL starting today 19:10:07 and he sent me updated copies of the font with license 19:10:09 cool 19:10:11 fabsh, sure what's up? 19:10:11 cool 19:10:23 can we only use it as is? 19:10:33 or could we modify it if we want/can? 19:10:36 you saw on list my report about Dave's responsivity with cantarell 19:10:41 fabsh, we can modify it under the OFL 19:10:47 oh sweet 19:10:50 and it seems Johan is willing to make updates too 19:10:57 nicubunu, yep that is fantastic news 19:11:00 ok, that answers it thanks 19:11:15 personally i think comfortaa looks pretty damn good :O 19:11:16 fabsh, it would have been a prob with the old license but we are good now :) 19:11:23 yeh it's coming out well in the web design work 19:11:25 its the capital i that gives me some headaches 19:11:27 goes great with the logo 19:11:28 and it looks great in muffin 19:11:51 i personally would remove the guides on it 19:11:57 yeah, its a great font 19:12:25 Emichan's presentation template used it too and it works well 19:12:33 i think our next steps now that the license is cahnged 19:12:36 is to get it packaged for Fedora 19:12:43 sounds good 19:12:57 and once that's done, we should replace MgOpen Modata with Comfortaa in our logo guidelines 19:13:08 +1 19:13:16 I agree. Comfortaa ++ 19:13:17 i'm going to do a font-of-the-week blog post on comfortaa to share the good news - 19:13:22 i promised i would to Johan 19:13:24 i will post to the list asking for that cahange 19:13:28 *change 19:13:29 and as part of that blog post, i'll try to locate a packager 19:13:31 otherwise +1 19:13:45 #action mizmo to post font-of-the-week blog post on comfortaa and try to find a packager 19:13:58 cool 19:14:03 okay lemme see our next topic 19:14:19 #topic New Design team join page (by Michael Beckwith) 19:14:19 okay 19:14:26 i was really bad and forgot to post this to the list for feedback 19:14:32 i was wondering if someone else could take this task up 19:14:48 the url is here: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Join_the_Design_Team 19:14:57 we need someone to post it to the design team list and ask for feedback 19:15:12 (or at least that's what we discussed doing last week) 19:15:14 what do you think? 19:15:22 didnt michael already do that? 19:15:31 what kind of feedback are we looking for? 19:15:46 * mizmo checks 19:15:52 http://lists.fedoraproject.org/pipermail/design-team/2010-July/002745.html 19:15:58 Schendje, ohhhh he did 19:15:59 okay 19:16:01 just that i think 19:16:03 hm 19:16:10 can folks look it over and post their feedback on it then? 19:16:19 he wanted to make more progress on it but was looking for suggestions 19:16:23 Emichan: ways to improve the page, make it more useful and friendly 19:16:29 like is there anything missin? what should he change? etc 19:16:42 can anyone commit to reviewing the design and posting suggestions on it? 19:16:58 but since is a wiki... we can operate the changes directly, without bureaucracy on list 19:18:36 yeh true 19:18:47 well if anyone wants to make the changes themselves :) 19:18:52 Michael said he wanted some help with it 19:18:57 I can commit to looking it over, esp as a new member, I used it before signing up 19:19:00 i think it's important to have a better page to explain how to join the team 19:19:05 Emichan, that would be wonderful, thank you! 19:19:15 * jimmac apologises for being late 19:19:22 #action Emichan to look over Michael's draft design team join page and review it https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Join_the_Design_Team 19:19:23 comfortaa++ 19:19:24 :) 19:19:26 jimmac, it's all good 19:19:53 okay so next topic 19:19:56 #topic fedoracommunity.org and Fedora website redesign 19:20:05 so i did a blog post yesterday on the latest fedoracommunity.org design 19:20:23 http://mairin.wordpress.com/2010/07/19/fedoracommunity-org-website-design/ 19:20:32 let me show you the latest for the website 19:20:46 http://duffy.fedorapeople.org/webdesign/fedoraproject.org/fedoraproject.org.4.png 19:20:55 i did that this morning.... i think maybe its getting too cluttered 19:21:10 looks great! 19:21:23 but, it seems maybe not as useful for folks who are contributors, but maybe it's more useful for folks who are new to fedora and wanting to try it, or folks who only use fedora 19:21:34 mizmo, i had an idea 19:21:38 let me show you this other crazy idea i had one sec 19:21:42 Schendje, go ahead! 19:22:13 existing contributors go directly to the wiki methinks 19:22:19 this is my crazy idea: http://duffy.fedorapeople.org/webdesign/fedoracontributors.org/fedoracontrib.org.png 19:22:23 not even finished 19:23:53 * jimmac likes the welcome dude 19:23:57 jimmac, lol 19:24:13 ideally i'd like to do new custom art there but i used placeholders for now 19:25:10 ive been looking at our old requirements list https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Website_redesign_2009_requirements#Tasks 19:25:14 when doing this 19:25:38 and it struck me that some of those things only contributors would really care about 19:25:42 i've been gathering all the things that "need" to be on there, and man it's a big list :P 19:26:03 Schendje, do you have your wiki url for that handy? 19:26:09 err wait ill get it 19:26:32 I like the idea of having a contributors site - and maintaining a consistent look across both sites is good usability 19:26:48 https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/User:Schendje/FPOcontent/#What_do_we_want_on_the_new_website.3F 19:26:55 a contributors site can be especially useful for new contributors and recruitment 19:26:56 on one level, fedora community (http://admin.fedoraproject.org/community) was supposed to be the contributors' site 19:27:19 but now we have fedoracommunity.org which is totally different, not a web app 19:27:27 and the community web app isn't really well socialized amongst the devels :( 19:27:29 i think it's a good idea to have a community hub.... 19:27:49 if i look at all of the things everybody wants on www.fpo... it's also a lot of things that could go to a dedicated page 19:27:56 the latest news from the community and such 19:28:01 anyway i was thinking... 19:28:15 there's two important goals for the www.fpo page (among others of course) 19:28:27 1) show visitors what fedora is (and a download link and such) 19:28:36 and 2) show the community and that everyone can join 19:28:50 so one's fedora purely as the OS 19:29:05 and the other is "the fedora project" 19:29:10 could we divide the page into two sections? 19:29:12 yeh i like that idea too schendje 19:29:21 one way to do is put the fedora the os at fedoradesktop.org 19:29:26 and hte community at fedoraproject.org 19:29:37 or keep the OS at fedoraproject.org, and move the communtiy to fedoracontributors.org 19:29:49 yeah 19:29:51 Schendje, i think having both on the same page is going to be confusing 19:29:55 but fedora the os is not just a desktop 19:30:20 nicubunu, what else is it 19:30:29 that most people would understand 19:30:30 a general purpose os 19:30:34 maybe that's why fedora-as-OS should stay on fpo - more general than a desktop 19:30:36 isnt this something the infrastructure team should be involved in as well? 19:30:37 eg if someone doesn't know what fedora is how do youexplain it to them 19:30:44 fabsh, yes they are as is the websites team 19:30:57 i know so many people running it as server... 19:30:59 fabsh, so if we have ideas here ill make sure they get fed back 19:31:01 ok. just making sure they are in the loop :) 19:31:08 nicubunu, thats not a particularly good usage of fedora though 19:31:12 nicubunu: really? Oo 19:31:19 nicubunu: as opposed to centos? 19:31:20 but that's what people do 19:31:20 nicubunu, eg if we tell people to use fedora as a server they are not going to have a good experience bc its not built for that 19:31:25 could work as long as we clearly separate them? right now it's all jumbled together anyway (is jumbled a word lol?) 19:31:28 my own server is centos :p 19:31:35 same here 19:31:39 anyway, i made this (rough messy and crowded, but as an idea): http://schendje.fedorapeople.org/temp/fedoraproject.org_edit5.png 19:31:40 i mean there are people who race shopping carts but i dont think anybody is going to sell the shopping cart as a racing vehicle 19:32:13 we could remove the "News" parts at the bottom and move those to a fedoracontributors.org page 19:32:23 since they take up a lot of space and some of it doesn't belong there 19:32:43 i think i could be ok with fedoralinux.org 19:32:44 Schendje, the news & planet & four foundations and in some part the events are really only of interest to current contributors though 19:32:55 yeah, those :) 19:33:00 nicubunu, linux is a separate trademark though i wonder if we can use it 19:33:14 but at the very least we need to show that we have a community, right? 19:33:29 it's not just about "this is fedora as a product" 19:33:37 community community community :) 19:33:44 Schendje, i think so but i dont think it shuld be front and center on the front page 19:33:47 Schendje, like, for example 19:33:50 true - part of the product IS the community 19:33:59 see the 'are you new?' box here http://duffy.fedorapeople.org/webdesign/fedoracontributors.org/fedoracontrib.org.png 19:34:14 maybe we could have a call out like that to bring people over to the website where we talk about our community and contributors 19:34:18 what's in the mockup right now.... one sec 19:34:20 well... the domain names are probably the competence of the board 19:34:29 http://duffy.fedorapeople.org/webdesign/fedoraproject.org/fedoraproject.org.4.png 19:34:46 see the globe icon, 'world wide community', that could point to more info on the community 19:35:02 also the 'about fedora' box 19:35:41 i think probably links like that could go to a page that talks just about how fedora is made 19:35:58 maybe with stats on our community, maybe a lit-up map to show where are our contributors are across the world (we autogenerate those regularly) 19:36:13 maybe some interviews with community members 19:36:17 kind of like we do on spins.fedoraproject.org 19:36:32 doesn't that kind of shove it into the background though? :( 19:36:55 it's not the main goal of the page 19:37:00 we can't do everything 100% on the very front page 19:37:06 i think the main point of the front page should be 19:37:11 'here's what fedora is, look!' 19:37:15 'download fedora and try it out!' 19:37:39 i think pushing too hard to get ppl to join the community when they are struggling to even understand what linux and what fedora is, is just going to overload people 19:38:19 that's a good point 19:38:24 yeah that's definitely true 19:38:41 so if we can focus on those two goals - #1 explain what fedora is and have people understand #2 get people to download and try fedora 19:38:45 focus on just those two and do them really well 19:38:51 i would think the people would look for 'help' more than joining on the homepage 19:38:58 i think we'll have a better shot at drawing people into deeper aspects of fedora without scaring them off 19:39:01 sijis, i agree 19:39:22 ok, but could we make it a little more.. .special? :P 19:39:24 but joining i think should be front and center - super easy - on a website geared towards contributors 19:39:32 yeah 19:39:35 yup! 19:39:39 but instead of throwing it in with the other links... 19:39:45 like this guy :) http://duffy.fedorapeople.org/webdesign/fedoracontributors.org/fedoracontrib.org.png 19:39:50 * sijis has never heard of fedoracontributor.org 19:39:54 till now 19:40:06 sijis, i just made it up 2 hours ago lol 19:40:25 experimenting around to see if it could work conceptually 19:40:26 oh. 19:40:52 yeah, something more like that... 19:40:53 at first thought, that's like join + more 19:40:55 because there were so many good fedora links i was ripping out of the fedoraproject.org page design bc they didn't make sense for newbies 19:41:19 i mean if i dont even know what fedora is or i'm downloading it for the first time, i'm not going to check the build system or care about it 19:41:41 very true. 19:41:41 instead of just throwing it in with the other features - making it something special since we're an open source project after all 19:41:56 doesn't have to take up much of the page or anything 19:42:01 Schendje, for what specifically 19:42:22 sorry? :) 19:42:32 Schendje, " instead of just throwing it" what is it 19:42:44 eg here we have 19:42:44 http://duffy.fedorapeople.org/webdesign/fedoraproject.org/fedoraproject.org.4.png 19:42:47 oh, right 19:42:50 "100% free& open source" with a link to more info 19:42:55 "Worldwide community" with a link to more info 19:43:00 a "Join" button in the main nav in the upper right 19:43:11 and the join category in the footer directory 19:43:16 i meant the "worldwide" community thing 19:43:38 Schendje, what is the problem you're trying to solve? 19:43:40 it has a big "Join us" below that though 19:44:04 yeh so there's 5 ways to get to info about joining the community on the mockup righ tnow 19:44:15 yeah that's true 19:44:31 is the problem you're trying to solve getting users to understand fedora is built by a community? 19:44:43 yep, instead of just showing it as a product 19:45:00 Schendje, but our goal #1 is to get them to understand what fedora is, and our goal #2 is to get them to download it 19:45:13 yes i agree 19:45:25 is understanding fedora is built by a community important to users when they are first doing those two things? 19:45:50 one thing that is noticeably missing from the page is a 'buy now' button which gives a hint that it's free too 19:46:11 and to some extent fedora is a product.... if people think it's a community only i think that's going to be a confusing introduction 19:46:27 the community products the OS 19:46:33 the community doesn't exist without to OS 19:46:44 so to understand what the community does, you have to understand what the OS is first 19:46:50 but people should understand is not just yet another windows 19:46:55 so, fedora is a community product :) 19:47:03 yes i see your point :) 19:47:07 nicubunu, are people going to try it just because it's built by a community? 19:47:14 or are they going to try it because it's different? 19:47:24 i mean the tagline right now is 'free your desktop' 19:47:37 "FEdora is a linux based operating system that offers the best in free & open source software...." 19:47:48 but our audience isn't necessarily all linux noobs 19:47:51 i kind of think right now that it's open source and free is stated multiple times on the page 19:48:00 do we want people to use fedora because is a cheaper alternative to windows? 19:48:19 Emichan, yeh that's true, they may be a current user (so they will then look to this page primarily for support / help or to communicate with other users) 19:48:25 or they may be using another distro and considering jumping to fedora 19:48:39 what about linux users moving to fedora from another distro? a great community is a big selling point for that kind of user... 19:48:41 but if they are considering jumping to fedora from another distro it's important for them to leran what makes fedora different 19:49:07 nicubunu, no but i dont see how this page design is saying 'cheaper alternative to windows' either 19:49:20 hmm 19:49:32 my point was: we still tell about the community 19:49:35 i guess im really confused 19:49:40 if you look at the very top of the page 19:49:47 "Fedora is a Linux-based operating system that showcases 19:49:47 the latest in free and open source software. Fedora is 19:49:47 always free for anyone to use, modify, and distribute. 19:49:47 It is built by people across the globe who work together 19:49:47 as a community: the Fedora Project. " 19:49:52 i dont understand what the problem is.... 19:49:55 help me! 19:50:03 how are we not telling about the community? 19:50:12 well it's true that it's mentioned a lot on the page... 19:50:33 i think it's not that we're not telling about the community as much as we're not SELLING the community 19:50:51 maybe we should have a section "what makes fedora differnet' to talk about why it is diff from other distros 19:50:58 but why would we sell the community 19:51:27 the user community? Or the developer community? 19:51:32 they are a bit different no 19:51:55 i was talking about the community as "anyone who helps developing fedora" 19:52:07 so im a user 19:52:11 i dont contribute to fedora 19:52:21 why do i care about the developer community 19:52:29 why does that sell fedora to me? 19:52:37 if its fun to work on fedora, but i won't work on it, then why do i care? 19:52:37 but i think it's also important to look on the community as part of the product - an important selling feature of the product that sets it apart 19:52:49 Emichan, sure but then wouldn't that go under the 'about fedora' section? 19:53:10 i mean 19:53:16 i totally see selling the community on the join page 19:53:29 where we're trying to get people excited about pitching in and learning about the cool people we have in our community 19:53:32 but i dont understand, 19:53:41 that's where i'd expect selling to occur.. on the join page 19:53:46 if our goal is to explain #1 what fedora is #2 get people to download and try it, why community needs to be front and center 19:53:51 we're just talking about the front page now right? 19:53:58 (that's all i've been talking about) 19:54:08 well i am :) 19:54:11 i agree with sijis that selling the comunity should be on the join page 19:54:23 i do see #3 probably being.. what makes Fedora different or what's new wtih Fedora 19:54:37 i am with mizmo on this one 19:54:39 if we add too many core messages/goals to the very front page, we risk losing all messages in communicating to the user 19:55:18 yeah i see what you're saying 19:55:21 anyways i think i sort of derailed the topic, sorry - should we get back to the meeting and talk about this another time? :D 19:55:26 I guess I'd just like to see the community be talked up on the front page as a "feature" of fedora, not necessarily as something wholly different 19:55:42 Emichan, well there little slideshow is meant to show off features of fedora 19:55:50 Emichan, the first slide is a basic - what is fedora 19:55:58 Emichan, but we could add a slide in there talking about our community as a feature 19:56:06 there is also a 'features' tab on the secondary nav bar 19:56:09 sure - a slide like that would be perfect 19:56:11 that could also talk about community 19:56:40 and in the little greyscale icon bar on the front page worldwide community is mentioned as a feature 19:56:59 Schendje, sure i hope im not being dense 19:57:10 this has been a really helpful discussion 19:57:23 there's at least two different users we can/should target: new users (know nothing at all about fedora) and distro hoppers (why is fedora differnt/better than distro X?) 19:57:44 I think community is a good feature to talk up to the latter user 19:57:46 Emichan, yep and i think distro hoppers are really important and this design right now might not be reaching them as well as it could 19:58:06 * sijis steps away 19:58:11 there are also the windows immigrants who may know *something* 19:58:12 maybe have a section in the main content area, "What Makes Fedora Different?" 19:58:22 and have that have some information on what makes fedora stand out from other distros 19:58:26 how we work differently 19:58:26 mizmo: nah i'll think about it a little more and talk about it on the channel some other time :) 19:58:27 agree 19:58:41 because right now that main content section is really just targeting total newbs 19:58:59 and we should be smart and reach out to other linux distro users & even smart windows immigrants 19:59:11 cool okay 19:59:13 we're running out of time 19:59:17 i wanted to discuss the tickets real quick 19:59:24 #topic design team ticket queue 19:59:50 i think pierros finished fedorahosted.org/design-team/ticket/138 19:59:58 yes, closed 20:00:15 and i think he sent out the email to ppl with missing hackergotchis too 20:00:30 that was ticket 139 20:00:31 but do we have any reaction? 20:00:41 im not sure, it looks like he didn't make the meeting 20:00:52 nicubunu, can you ask him if he's heard back from anybody on the missing hackergotchis yet? 20:01:08 he instructed people to fill tickets 20:01:21 ah okay 20:01:31 * mizmo checks to see if we've new hackergotchi tickets 20:01:42 ..... 20:01:45 oh right and https://fedorahosted.org/design-team/ticket/142 i created a wiki page with guidelines 20:01:56 i dont see any new ones yet 20:02:12 so the reaction was minimal 20:02:25 Schendje, awesome great job 20:02:26 well 20:02:33 i think we did well advertising the service on the blogs 20:02:37 and letting people know 20:02:53 there isnt much more we can do i guess if people aren't interested :( 20:03:07 #info pierros completed tickets 138 and 139 20:03:14 #info Schendje completed ticket 142 20:03:37 we can harass people with comments on their blogs, but i won't do that 20:03:44 lol 20:03:49 so for a new ticket we have this one 20:03:50 https://fedorahosted.org/design-team/ticket/143 20:03:57 its to create a tshirt design for summer coding 2010 20:04:03 so as you might imagine it's pretty time-sensitive 20:04:14 i am wondering if anybody is interested in picking it up 20:04:19 nobody owns the tickt right now 20:04:49 if nobody is interested maybe i can make it the next bounty 20:05:04 okay 20:05:15 so we're over by 5 minutes now, so i'm going to go ahead and end the meeting 20:05:20 thanks everyone for coming 20:05:21 :) 20:05:25 #endmeeting