Our purpose in this meeting is to review
proposed blocker and nice-to-have bugs and decide whether to accept
them, and to monitor the progress of fixing existing accepted
blocker and nice-to-have bugs.(tflink,
17:12:36)
We'll be following the process outlined
at:(tflink,
17:12:43)
(877658) [i18n] some storage-related error messages not marked for translation: "Not enough free space on disks for automatic partitioning"(tflink, 17:17:56)
AGREED: 877658 -
AcceptedBlocker - Violation of the following F18 final release
criterion: "All critical path actions on release-blocking desktop
environments should correctly display all sufficiently complete
translations available for use"(tflink,
17:21:57)
(883699) Changing LV name in custom partitioning crashes installer (TypeError: Argument 2 does not allow None as a value)(tflink, 17:22:08)
AGREED: 883699 -
AcceptedBlocker - Violates the following F18 final release criterion
when modifying any volume name in custom partitioning: " The
installer must be able to create and install to any workable
partition layout using any file system offered in a default
installer configuration, LVM, software, hardware or BIOS RAID, or
combination of the above"(tflink,
17:27:27)
AGREED: 883699 -
AcceptedBlocker - Violates the following F18 beta release criterion:
"The installer's custom partitioning mode must be capable of the
following ... Rejecting obviously invalid operations without
crashing"(tflink,
17:31:54)
(886061) 'fedora' or 'updates' repository error must be fatal, otherwise the upgraded system might be broken heavily(tflink, 17:32:02)
AGREED: 886061 -
RejectedBlocker - With the changes in fedup coming for F18, this bug
is no longer as serious as it was and thus, does not qualify for
release blocking status for F18 final(tflink,
17:37:47)
(875846) [i18n] "ON" and "OFF" not translated in switches on DVD (gtk30.mo not on DVD)(tflink, 17:37:56)
AGREED: 875846 -
AcceptedBlocker - Violates the following F18 final release
criterion: "All critical path actions on release-blocking desktop
environments should correctly display all sufficiently complete
translations available for use"(tflink,
17:43:09)
(872851) [abrt] rhythmbox-2.98-4.fc18: Process /usr/bin/rhythmbox was killed by signal 11 (SIGSEGV)(tflink, 17:43:19)
AGREED: 872851 -
RejectedBlocker - While rhythmbox is a default application, this bug
requires enabling of a non-default plugin and thus does not qualify
for release blocking status for F18 final.(tflink,
17:46:52)
(861280) KDE Crashes or Hangs After Moving Konqueror Window Quickly(tflink, 17:47:00)
AGREED: 860022 -
AcceptedNTH - We need more information on how many repos are being
used to trigger this and if the updates.img from comment#20 works
before deciding on blocker status. However, this is bad enough to
warrant NTH status - a tested fix would be considered past
freeze.(tflink,
17:58:13)
AGREED: 882212 -
AcceptedNTH - This does affect upgrades with yum which aren't
recommended but aren't uncommon. A tested fix would be considered
past freeze.(tflink,
18:17:49)
(886647) Anaconda throws exception trying to setup network if non-existing network --device is specified in kickstart(tflink, 18:18:05)
AGREED: 886647 -
RejectedBlocker AcceptedNTH - This is too much of a corner case to
take as a blocker but it can't be fixed with an update and a
non-trivial number of people could hit this. A tested fix would be
considered past freeze.(tflink,
18:21:33)
(888107) Shell leaking memory with every interaction with the panel(tflink, 18:31:04)
AGREED: 888107 -
AcceptedNTH - This isn't quite a blocker but causes problems for
lives, especially in lower memory situations. A tested fix would be
considered past freeze.(tflink,
18:35:11)
(830181) Logout/shutdown/restart should be inhibited while Apper is performing updates(tflink, 18:35:21)
AGREED: 830181 -
RejectedNTH - Taking PK fixes this close to release is unwise and
since this bug wouldn't affect live images and thus could be fixed
with an update - rejected as NTH for F18 final(tflink,
18:41:52)
(875567) anaconda doesnt set keyboard layout for LUKS password at reboot(tflink, 18:42:01)
AGREED: 875567 -
AcceptedNTH - This is borderline blocker since LUKS passwords are
affected but not all installations are affected by this. A tested
fix would be considered past freeze.(tflink,
18:49:57)
(876916) anaconda claims I don't have enough free space when I have(tflink, 18:51:46)
AGREED: 876916 -
AcceptedNTH - This isn't critical but it would be good to have
effective minimum space detection and this can't be fixed with an
update. A tested fix would be considered past freeze.(tflink,
18:56:55)
(882233) Chinese (Taiwan) shows Simplified Chinese instead of Traditional Chinese at left (native language view) side(tflink, 18:57:06)
AGREED: 882233 - We
would like to have more information on how bugs like this have been
handled in the past - there isn't a clear universal answer which all
parties would like. Will revisit when there's more info.(tflink,
19:16:13)
(886463) Keyboard layout switching is confusing on LiveCD(tflink, 19:16:22)
AGREED: 886463 -
AcceptedNTH - Adding the warning message seems like a good idea
without much risk. A tested fix would be considered past
freeze.(tflink,
19:21:48)
(887112) Existing Windows 7 appears under \'Unknown\' in Manual Partitioning(tflink, 19:21:55)
AGREED: 887112 -
RejectedNTH - While this might be a nice visual enhancement, it
isn't a huge deal and represents a bit more risk than we'd like to
see so late in the release.(tflink,
19:27:12)
(888112) Yellow error display bar is incapable of wrapping long errors, they are too wide and overflow the side of the screen(tflink, 19:27:20)
AGREED: 888112 -
AcceptedNTH - This is a very useful visual enhancement without much
risk and can't be fixed with an update. A tested fix would be
considered past freeze.(tflink,
19:31:14)
(888603) Custom partitioning shouldn't let you set /boot as btrfs(tflink, 19:31:24)
AGREED: 888603 -
AcceptedNTH - This is a safety check to disallow a non-obviously
invalid operation and is relatively low risk. A tested fix would be
considered past freeze.(tflink,
19:33:30)
(886556) missing icons in yumex & apper(tflink, 19:33:43)
AGREED: 886556 -
RejectedNTH - While this is a polish issue that would be good to
fix, it's late in the release and the risk of taking this fix so
late is not clearly low (could affect PK, apper etc.).(tflink,
19:43:44)
(855697) No way to change the language on Live(tflink, 19:44:38)
AGREED: 855697 -
AcceptedNTH - While there are a couple ideas in the bug, there is an
available fix upstream to add a logout button to the language/region
applet - a tested fix would be considered past freeze but only if it
is the fix from upstream - other fixes would need to be reproposed
for NTH status(tflink,
19:51:27)
(873849) no keyboard shortcut for toggling keyboard layouts(tflink, 19:51:34)
AGREED: 873849 - It
isn't completely clear what the fix for this might be or whether
there is developer support for a fix. Will re-visit when more info
is available(tflink,
19:59:59)
(886077) Custom shortcut super+'char' writes the char or does nothing instead of execute demanded action(tflink, 20:00:13)
AGREED: 886077 -
RejectedNTH - While this is an inconvenience, it involves setting
custom actions which is unlikely to affect live images and thus can
be fixed with an update.(tflink,
20:08:43)
(888395) 3.6.11 update for kernel(tflink, 20:08:51)
AGREED: 888395 -
RejectedNTH - This would only fix media sourced upgrades for a very
short time and would not affect network sourced upgrades. Since
there are no other critical reasons to upgrade the released kernel,
rejected as NTH for F18 final.(tflink,
20:12:14)
(872162) error creating partitions on LVM volume created with allocation=0(tflink, 20:12:22)
AGREED: 872162 -
RejectedNTH - This involves VM creation which is not likely to
affect live images and isn't the default path for VM creation
anyways. It could be fixed with an update and doesn't need to be
pulled past freeze.(tflink,
20:16:10)
(884878) FirewallConfig in imgcreate/kickstart.py requires FirewallD(tflink, 20:16:18)
AGREED: 884878 -
AcceptedNTH - Enabling spins to ship without firewalld is desirable
as long as the fix isn't too bad. A tested fix would be considered
past freeze.(tflink,
20:19:53)
(821221) ibus-setup language selection entries shadowed out(tflink, 20:20:01)
AGREED: 821221 -
RejectedNTH - There appear to be no extra IMEs on the KDE live media
and thus, this would not affect lives and could be fixed with an
update.(tflink,
20:35:58)
(875430) After installing unable to boot Fedora 18 with virtio-scsi after successfully installing using virtio-scsi driver (have to use virtio-blk to boot)(tflink, 20:36:08)
AGREED: 875430 -
AcceptedNTH - Allowing non-primary storage drivers in a VM would be
preferred and a relatively small, tested fix would be considered
past freeze.(tflink,
20:41:29)
(886208) systemd should mount efivarfs by default on UEFI machines(tflink, 20:41:37)
AGREED: 886208 -
RejectedNTH - This wouldn't affect the released version of F18 since
it's for personal/private signing of shim and could be fixed with an
update.(tflink,
20:52:16)
(879922) Fails to open from the Xfce menu.(tflink, 20:56:04)
AGREED: 849347 -
RejectedNTH - This seems rather limited in the HW affected and
doesn't happen all of the time - it's too late in the release
process to be taking non-showstopper bugs for F18.(tflink,
21:07:10)
(816073, 820154, 816389, 884274) rdma and srptools for F18(tflink, 21:10:00)
AGREED: 816073,
820154, 816389, 884274 - AcceptedNTH - Due to the nature of these
changes, they cannot be pushed post-release due to updates policy,
are unlikely to break anything else and contain security fixes.
Builds would be considered past freeze if they had enough
karma.(tflink,
21:17:27)
AGREED: 882976 -
AcceptedNTH - Memory leaks are bad and this could affect live
images, making it not possible to fix with an update in all cases. A
tested fix would be considered past freeze.(tflink,
21:24:13)